Dancers

Maker DeCarava, Roy American, 1919-2009

Date1956, printed 1981

MediumGelatin silver print

Dimensionsmat: 20 in x 16 in; paper: 13 7/8 in x 9 5/8 in

Credit LineMuseum purchase

Object number1988:45

About the ArtistRoy Rudolph DeCarava was born in New York City’s Harlem, on December 9, 1919. From 1938 to 1940 he studied painting at Cooper Union Institute, from 1940 to 1942 painting and printmaking with Elton Fax at the Harlem Art Center, and drawing and painting with Charles White at George Washington Carver Art School in 1944. He originally purchased a camera (in 1946) to document his work in printmaking, but by 1949 photography itself was his sole artistic focus. He went on to establish himself as a post-war street photographer of daily life, specifically Black life in New York. DeCarava was not the first photographer to shoot Harlem, but his commitment to interpreting it in artistic terms sets him apart from the history of social documentary established there.

His first photography exhibition was in 1950 at Mark Pepper’s Forty Fourth Street Gallery. There were 160 prints in exhibition, and Edward Steichen purchased three for the Museum of Modern Art’s collection. There Homor Page, a student of Steiglitz, befriended DeCarava and began discussing darkroom technique with him. Soon thereafter, DeCarava started to experiment with a darker tonal range. His studies of the New York jazz world, begun a few years later, further developed his penchant for dark printing. While the deep tones in his pictures sometimes push the edge of legibility, both true blacks and true whites are rare.

In 1952, DeCarava became the first Black recipient of a John Simon Guggenheim Memorial Fellowship. The year of the fellowship was remarkably fruitful, producing such important prints as Nightfeeding. At first rejected by publishers, photographs from the project were eventually published with the help of Langston Hughes in 1955 as The Sweet Flypaper of Life. Shortly thereafter, DeCarava opened one of the first galleries in New York devoted to photography, A Photographer’s Gallery, which would feature exhibitions of Bernice Abbott, Harry Callahan, and Minor White in the two years it was open. At the same time, he began a series on jazz musicians that would occupy him for a decade.

In a series of taped interviews with Sherry Turner DeCarava (published in Roy DeCarava Photographs), Roy DeCarava had much to say about his 1956 piece Dancers, uptown ‘club dance,’ New York:

“This photograph was taken at a dance of a social club at the 110th St. Manor at Fifth Avenue. It is about the intermission where they had entertainment and the entertainment was two dancers who danced to jazz music. That’s what this image is all about; it’s about these two dancers who represent a terrible torment for me in that I feel a great ambiguity about the image because of them. It’s because they are in some ways distorted characters. What they actually are is two Black male dancers who dance in the manner of an older generation of Black vaudeville performers. The problem comes because their figures remind me so much of the real life experience of Blacks in their need to but themselves in an awkward position before the man, for the man; to demean themselves in order to survive, to get along. In a way, these figures seem to epitomize that reality. And yet there is something in the figures not about that; something in the figures that is very creative, that is very real and very Black in the finest sense of the word. So there is this duality this ambiguity in the photograph that I find very hard to live with. I always have to make a decision in a case like this – is it good or is it bad? I have to say that even though it jars some of my sensibilities and reminds me of things that I would rather not be reminded of, it is still a good picture. In fact, it is good just because of those things and in spite of those things. The picture works.”

Roy DeCarava’s work was included in the Museum of Modern Art’s Family of Man exhibition. In 1958, he began to take on commercial projects, and his pictures have appeared in such periodicals as Sports Illustrated, Look, Newsweek, Time, and Life. He ran the Kamoinge Workshop for young Black photographers from 1963 to 1966. In 1969, he refused to be a part of the Metropolitan Museum of Art’s exhibition Harlem on My Mind, critiquing its conception of Black artists and its marginalization of photography as an art form. He began teaching at Hunter College in New York City in 1975, where he became a full professor of art. In 1992, Wesleyan University awarded him the honorary degree of doctor of fine arts.

In 1996, The Museum of Modern Art in New York held a retrospective of his work.
His work has also been presented in solo exhibitions at Friends of Photography, Carmel, California; Akron Art Institute, Ohio; Port Washington Public Library, New York; Witkin Gallery, New York; Light Work Gallery, Syracuse, New York; Corcoran Gallery, Washington, DC; Museum of Fine Arts, Houston; Camera Club of New York; and New York Public Library. DeCarava’s photographs are included in the collections of Museum of Modern Art, New York; Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York; Harlem Art Collection, New York State Office Building, New York; Andover Arts Gallery, Phillips Academy, Andover, Massachusetts; Corcoran Gallery, Washington, DC; Atlanta University; Sheldon Memorial Art Gallery, University of Nebraska, Lincoln; Museum of Fine Arts, Houston; and Center for Creative Photography, University of Arizona, Tucson. He died in 2009.